Otwarty dostęp

A study on the construction of a data-driven civic assessment system for the course of composition and work analysis

Dan Wang

Dan Wang

College of Music and Dance, Hebei Minzu Normal UniversityChengde, China
Wyszukaj tego autora
Sciendo|Google Scholar
Wang, Dan
, 
Yue Li

Yue Li

College of Music and Dance, Hebei Minzu Normal UniversityChengde, China
Wyszukaj tego autora
Sciendo|Google Scholar
Li, Yue
 oraz 
Haidong Wang

Haidong Wang

College of Music and Dance, Hebei Minzu Normal UniversityChengde, China
Wyszukaj tego autora
Sciendo|Google Scholar
Wang, Haidong
  
03 lut 2025
A study on the construction of a data-driven civic assessment system for the course of composition and work analysis's Cover Image
O artykule
Poprzedni artykuł
Następny artykuł
Zacytuj
Pobierz okładkę
Data publikacji: 03 lut 2025
Otrzymano: 26 wrz 2024
Przyjęty: 01 sty 2025
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/amns-2025-0037
Słowa kluczowe
© 2025 Dan Wang et al., published by Sciendo
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Figure 1.

The basic framework of the CIPP evaluation mode
The basic framework of the CIPP evaluation mode

Figure 2.

The judgment matrix of the first level index
The judgment matrix of the first level index

Teaching evaluation index system weight

Primary indicator EWM Composite weight Secondary indicator EWM Composite weight Tertiary index EWM Composite weight Absolute weight
A1 0.2746 0.0601 B1 0.5 0.5 C1 0.3057 0.3057 0.0092
C2 0.3836 0.3836 0.0115
C3 0.3107 0.3108 0.0093
B2 0.5 0.5 C4 0.5123 0.3377 0.0102
C5 0.4877 0.6623 0.0199
A2 0.2473 0.1244 B3 0.5426 0.5029 C6 0.5 0.5 0.0313
C7 0.5 0.5 0.0313
B4 0.4574 0.4971 C8 0.5528 0.3952 0.0244
C9 0.4472 0.6048 0.0374
A3 0.2623 0.3712 B5 0.4875 0.3527 C11 0.3561 0.4520 0.0592
C12 0.3414 0.2616 0.0343
C13 0.3025 0.2864 0.0375
B6 0.5125 0.6473 C14 0.3768 0.4384 0.1053
C15 0.6232 0.5616 0.1349
A4 0.2158 0.4443 B7 0.4239 0.6954 C16 0.3143 0.2863 0.0885
C17 0.3218 0.4977 0.1538
C18 0.1285 0.0717 0.0221
C19 0.2354 0.1443 0.0446
B8 0.5761 0.3046 C20 1 1 0.1353

The evaluation index weight based on AHP

Primary indicator Wai Secondary indicator Wbi Tertiary index Wci Absolute weight
A1 0.0521 B1 0.5 C1 0.3333 0.0087
C2 0.3333 0.0087
C3 0.3334 0.0087
B2 0.5 C4 0.3268 0.0085
C5 0.6732 0.0175
A2 0.1199 B3 0.4603 C6 0.5 0.0276
C7 0.5 0.0276
B4 0.5397 C8 0.3458 0.0224
C9 0.6542 0.0423
A3 0.3373 B5 0.3642 C11 0.4256 0.0523
C12 0.2569 0.0316
C13 0.3175 0.0390
B6 0.6358 C14 0.5635 0.1208
C15 0.4365 0.0936
A4 0.4907 B7 0.6667 C16 0.2511 0.0821
C17 0.4263 0.1395
C18 0.1537 0.0503
C19 0.1689 0.0553
B8 0.3333 C20 1 0.1635

The evaluation membership of the tertiary index

Evaluation index Evaluation grade
V1 V2 V3 V4 V5
B1 C1(0.3057) 0.1465 0.2999 0.4099 0.0612 0.0825
C2(0.3836) 0.0575 0.4594 0.2829 0.1221 0.0781
C3(0.3108) 0.0714 0.3842 0.3988 0.1427 0.0029
B2 C4(0.3377) 0.1382 0.5196 0.2279 0.1143 0.0000
C5(0.6623) 0.1534 0.5144 0.2793 0.0529 0.0000
B3 C6(0.5) 0.0656 0.4249 0.4461 0.0065 0.0569
C7(0.5) 0.1436 0.4871 0.3528 0.0165 0.0000
B4 C8(0.3952) 0.0233 0.2629 0.4321 0.1973 0.0844
C9(0.6048) 0.0104 0.3776 0.3881 0.1638 0.0601
B5 C11(0.4520) 0.1117 0.4685 0.3394 0.0804 0.0000
C12(0.2616) 0.0658 0.4568 0.2338 0.1227 0.1209
C13(0.2864) 0.1756 0.4965 0.1939 0.0904 0.0436
B6 C14(0.43847) 0.0114 0.4565 0.4195 0.0682 0.0444
C15(0.5616) 0.0689 0.3992 0.3343 0.1976 0.0000
B7 C16(0.2863) 0.1113 0.4896 0.3157 0.0834 0.0000
C17(0.4977) 0.1177 0.2663 0.4811 0.1349 0.0000
C18(0.0717) 0.1996 0.4107 0.3635 0.0081 0.0181
C19(0.1443) 0.0553 0.4337 0.3737 0.0517 0.0856
B8 C20(1) 0.0567 0.5515 0.3182 0.0497 0.0239

Preliminary evaluation index system

Primary indicator Secondary indicator Tertiary index
A1 B1 C1
C2
C3
B2 C4
C5
A2 B3 C6
C7
B4 C8
C9
C10
A3 B5 C11
C12
C13
B6 C14
C15
A4 B7 C16
C17
C18
C19
B8 C20

The evaluation membership of the secondary indicator

Evaluation index Evaluation grade
V1 V2 V3 V4 V5
A1 (0.0601) B1(0.5) 0.0890 0.3873 0.3577 0.1099 0.0561
B2(0.5) 0.1483 0.5162 0.2619 0.0736 0.0000
A2 (0.1244) B3(0.5029) 0.1046 0.4560 0.3995 0.0115 0.0284
B4(0.4971) 0.0155 0.3323 0.4055 0.1770 0.0697
A3 (0.3712) B5(0.3527) 0.1180 0.4735 0.2701 0.0943 0.0441
B6(0.6473) 0.0437 0.4243 0.3716 0.1409 0.0195
A4 (0.4443) B7(0.6954) 0.1127 0.3647 0.4098 0.0991 0.0137
B8(0.3046) 0.0567 0.5515 0.3182 0.0497 0.0239
Język:
Angielski
Częstotliwość wydawania:
1 razy w roku
Dziedziny czasopisma:
Nauki biologiczne, Nauki biologiczne, inne, Matematyka, Matematyka stosowana, Matematyka ogólna, Fizyka, Fizyka, inne
Kanał RSS czasopisma